McNabb

[Hard Rain]

Anybody catch this about McNabb? (http://sports.espn.go.com/nfl/news/story?id=2258970)

From the black guy three weeks ago~
"In essence Donny, you are mediocre at best," Mondesire wrote. "And trying to disguise that fact behind some concocted reasoning that African American quarterbacks who can scramble and who can run the ball are somehow lesser field generals ... is more insulting off the field than on."
From the white guy two years ago~
When Limbaugh said on ESPN two years ago that McNabb is overrated because the media wanted to see a black quarterback succeed, the NAACP criticized the conservative commentator and called on him to quit. Limbaugh resigned from ESPN three days later.
I think McNabb has been overrated for awhile, and I'm white, does that make me a bigot? Any chance the NAACP will call on Mondesire to quit as well?

[NYG 5]

mcnabb is overrated because all he can do is scramble. same with vick.
steve mcnair is still better than both of them since he can pass, and cuz hes tough as nails.

[josh_moore1]

mcnabb is overrated because all he can do is scramble. same with vick.
steve mcnair is still better than both of them since he can pass, and cuz hes tough as nails.

your exactly right

[1iNcHWoNDeR]

Put Vick or Mcnabb on a losing team, and keep them healthy all year long. Lets see how much you hear about them. Then put Mcnair on a winning team. I bet you people will think hes the best.

[jn_powell]

mcnabb is overrated because all he can do is scramble. same with vick.
steve mcnair is still better than both of them since he can pass, and cuz hes tough as nails.
First off, if Mcnair is such a superior passer, how come he only averages about 2 more yards per game passing over his career than McNabb. And as far as toughness goes, after what Mcnabb went through this year, all while continuing to play, I don't think his toughness should really be put into question. And who led his team to the NFC championship year after year after year.

[1iNcHWoNDeR]

I think its complete bullshit how people say Mcnabb (Even though I hate the Eagles) and Vick, can't pass. Why the fuck would they be a quarterback then. Exactly. They would run or catch or some shit, but not throw.

[NYG 5]

First off, if Mcnair is such a superior passer, how come he only averages about 2 more yards per game passing over his career than McNabb. And as far as toughness goes, after what Mcnabb went through this year, all while continuing to play, I don't think his toughness should really be put into question. And who led his team to the NFC championship year after year after year.

look what happens when the nfc east actually becomes competent? and do u notice how mcnabbs stats were really going down the shitter towards the redskin game? and they can only play qb because the defense has to adjust itself to protect from qb scramble, sacrificing pass defense. now that teams are figuring out how to stop their runs and force them to pass, they are nothing. example: vick vs bears. mcnabb isnt such a great leader as u say. throwing the ugliest ducks during the sb. and how during the last 2 minutes of the game, the eagles had to slow down for mcchoke. leading his team to the nfc championship year after year. and lose year after year too. give me brad johson, give me peyton manning, ive me byron leftwich. hell, as much as i hate o say it, give me tom brady. f**k these damn scramblers.