Best QB of all time (ROUND 2)

[soso0901]

Alright, the first round of this thing is over. To view that thread and the general rules of what I'm doing click here (http://forum.ebaumsworld.com/showthread.php?t=121494).

Now we're ready for round 2. Here are the rules for this round:

Since there was a tie for the 5th place spot there will be 6 QBs in this round.

You will vote for who you think is THE WORST QB out of this list. The voting will end on monday and whoever has the most votes will be eliminated and the field will narrow to five.

Again, for those of you who are retarded... In this round you are eliminating one QB from the field. Vote for who you think is the worst of the available QBs.

If you accidently vote for who you think is the best that's just too bad, I'm not going to go through the effort of re-calculating for people who are fuck-tards.

So here are your 6 QBs along with the number of votes they recieved in the first round (a total of 53 people voted and you could vote for 5 QBs):

Dan Marino - 42 votes
Joe Montana - 41 votes
John Elway - 34 votes
Brett Favre - 23 votes
Johnny Unitas - 23 votes
Steve Young - 23 votes

The QBs that were cut are as follows:
Terry Bradshaw - 13 votes
Troy Aikmen - 12 votes
Bart Starr - 13 votes
Jim Kelly - 8 votes

Keep in mind that the number of votes they recieved last round doesn't matter anymore, I just wanted to let everyone know how they all did and to show that I'm not just advancing who I want to.

[baumy300]

It's hard to say "worst" because they are all so good. But I am going to have to go with Brett Favre.

He had his moments, but wasn't as consistent as the rest of these guys. Still good though.

[wils0646]

It's hard to say "worst" because they are all so good. But I am going to have to go with Brett Favre.

He had his moments, but wasn't as consistent as the rest of these guys. Still good though.

Na, I think it's just because you're a Queens fan :p.

[Nick is cool]

Na, I think it's just because you're a Queens fan :p.



Na, hes right. Brett favre is the worst out of them

[wils0646]

Na, hes right. Brett favre is the worst out of them

Na, I think Unitas or Young are worse than Favre. Stats and longevity don't lie.

[atreyu_2020]

Steve Young, he had great weapons and was put into an easy system....definitely the "worst" of them.

[PhyuckYu]

It's hard to say "worst" because they are all so cute. But I am going to have to go with Brett Favre.

He had his moments, but wasn't as consistent as the rest of these guys. Still good though.

[poopchow]

I said favre although i am still iffy. He did make his teammates better but young's stats are better in proportion to bretts. Brett has a few more years of playing than Steve

[/Tilt/]

Take off my vote for Elway. This poll is ghey.

[patriotwarrior7]

I'm going with Favre on this one,He past his prime in 2000.
Never,Could get Green Bay back to the Super Bowl.

[Kyuu]

Farve loses points for throwing so many INTs.

[Wu-tang]

Favre's only getting these points because of his last season...Brett was a badass gunslinger. Probally the toughest QB ever. I'm not saying Brett's the best, but he is good and I don't think he's the worst here. Of course it comes to a point where it starts becoming opinionated because you can't factually prove who is better out of these hall-of-famers and future hall-of-famers. But I wouldn't call him the worse here, just saying.

[firepiss]

This was the hardest poll I've ever taken.

I voted for Brett, but didn't mean too.

[YankeesSuck]

Take off my vote for Elway. This poll is ghey.

lol Who did you want to vote for?

[wsuwarrior]

i know Brett will get more hate votes than anything....stats say hes 2 or 3 all time. Only 3 time MVP, and hes got a Super Bowl ring....

Hard to win when you get hate from vikings fans, bears fans, and broncos fans....and theres a lot of those guys here. This poll proves nothing but who has more fans.

[Nerdcraft]

I voted Farve.

[atreyu_2020]

i know Brett will get more hate votes than anything....stats say hes 2 or 3 all time. Only 3 time MVP, and hes got a Super Bowl ring....

Hard to win when you get hate from vikings fans, bears fans, and broncos fans....and theres a lot of those guys here. This poll proves nothing but who has more fans.

Usually I dont agree with you, but this board is filled with flammering idiots who think Steve Young was bettre than Brett Favre.

[poopchow]

I didnt really count last season for brett. I think that if steve played as long as brett he would have had a better total career.

Steve Youngs stats

[1st] Most Consecutive Seasons Leading League, Passing - 4 (1991-1994)
[1st] Highest Passer Rating, Career - 96.8
[1st] Highest Passer Rating, Season - 112.8 (1994)
[1st] Highest Completion Percentage, Career - 64.28
[1st] Most Consecutive Games, 300 or More Yards Passing - 6 (1998)
[Tied for 1st] Most Seasons Leading League, Passing Touchdowns - 4 (1992, 1993, 1994, 1998)
[Tied for 1st] Most Seasons Leading League, Passing - 6 (1991, 1992, 1993, 1994, 1996, 1997)
[2nd] Most Consecutive Seasons Leading League, Completion Percentage - 4 (1994-1997)
[2nd] Most Seasons Leading League, Average Gain Passing - 5 (1991, 1992, 1993, 1994, 1997)
[2nd] Most Consecutive Seasons Leading League, Average Gain Passing - 4 (1991-1994)
[Tied for 2nd] Most Consecutive Seasons Leading League, Passing Touchdowns - 3 (1992-1994)
[Tied for 2nd] Most Consecutive Seasons Leading League, Passing - 2 (1996-1997)
[Tied for 2nd] Most Consecutive Passes Completed - 20 (vs. Washington, Nov. 24, 1996)
[3rd] Highest Completion Percentage, Season - 70.28 (1994)
[Tied for 3rd] Most Seasons Leading League, Completion Percentage - 5 (1992, 1994, 1995, 1996, 1997)
[Tied for 3rd] Most Games 300 or More Yards Passing, Season - 7 (1998)
[Tied for 3rd] Longest Pass Completion - 97 yards (to John Taylor, vs. Atlanta, Nov. 3, 1991)
[Tied for 3rd] Most Games, Four or More Touchdown Passes Season - 4 (1994)

[2000 civic si]

Montana hands down. 4 super bowl rings, compared to what, Steve's and Brett's 1 super bowl ring. Hell, Montana has won more super bowls than Young, Favre, and Elway combined. Sure stats are important, but Championships define your career and legacy.

[Jimothy51]

Montana hands down. 4 super bowl rings, compared to what, Steve's and Brett's 1 super bowl ring. Hell, Montana has won more super bowls than Young, Favre, and Elway combined. Sure stats are important, but Championships define your career and legacy.
You're supposed to vote for the worst out of the 6.

[Wu-tang]

Montana hands down. 4 super bowl rings, compared to what, Steve's and Brett's 1 super bowl ring. Hell, Montana has won more super bowls than Young, Favre, and Elway combined. Sure stats are important, but Championships define your career and legacy.
Yeah...didn't you think it seemed funny when Favre and Young got the most votes?

[2000 civic si]

Shit, I guess I can't read. Damn, and I voted Montana, really meant to put favre then. I was woundering why only one other person besides myself voted for Montana.

[poopchow]

Montana hands down. 4 super bowl rings, compared to what, Steve's and Brett's 1 super bowl ring. Hell, Montana has won more super bowls than Young, Favre, and Elway combined. Sure stats are important, but Championships define your career and legacy.


Leave it to an iggles fan to fuck it up.

[Wu-tang]

Well it's tied between Steve and Favre.

[atreyu_2020]

Montana hands down. 4 super bowl rings, compared to what, Steve's and Brett's 1 super bowl ring. Hell, Montana has won more super bowls than Young, Favre, and Elway combined. Sure stats are important, but Championships define your career and legacy.

If your theory is correct, looks like Big Ben is on his way to be the greatest QB of all time :cool:

[soso0901]

If your theory is correct, looks like Big Ben is on his way to be the greatest QB of all time :cool:

His passer rating of 22.6 in the Superbowl is just further proof of greatness. :rollseyes

I'm kidding by the way, I think he's a great QB and if the rest of his career goes the way his first two years have he probably will be remembered as one of the greatest.

[atreyu_2020]

His passer rating of 22.6 in the Superbowl is just further proof of greatness. :rollseyes

I'm kidding by the way, I think he's a great QB and if the rest of his career goes the way his first two years have he probably will be remembered as one of the greatest.

So? He has a ring....thats that civic was pointing at, rings define your career, Big Ben has one in his second year..

Oh, and his QB rating might have been bad, but check out the crucial plays he did make in order to lead his team to a victory.

Oh, and then look at the last 3 games before the Superbowl.. :cool:

[2000 civic si]

Leave it to an iggles fan to fuck it up.


Yes poop, even Iggles fans has their moments.