Fave metallica album after black!!

[vrettason]

basically your fave metallica album since they stopped playing thrash and became a hard rock band...
i think mine is reload or garage inc
PS. s&m doesnt count

[ConanTL]

S&M for me

[ThePope#15]

Load for me.

[The_Murphulator]

I guess load, but arent they making another album?

[Lounge Fly]

they all suck beyond belief im afraid

[ThePope#15]

I guess load, but arent they making another album?
I believe they are. Don't know the details though.

[judge weiner]

They're recording with Rick Rubin. Sounds like it could be promising if this happened like 10 years ago.

The only post-Black album I have is St. Anger so I'm going to have to pass on this question, although some of the singles from Load and Reload are okay.

Does Garage Inc count? I have that one and it's pretty good at times.

[Solaris]

I'd say Reload, seconded by S&M.

I think Metallica fans are too critical of their post Black Album stuff.

[hipocritical]

I think Metallica fans are too critical of their post Black Album stuff.

No, for the most part, it just plain sucks in comparison.

[Lounge Fly]

No, for the most part, it just plain sucks in comparison.

it sucks even compared to most modern rock/metal & thats saying something..talk about fall from grace

[KEALYBOY]

Either 'Welcome To Da Chuuch Vol. 2' or 'Tha Doggfather'...

[hipocritical]

it sucks even compared to most modern rock/metal & thats saying something..talk about fall from grace

It just plain sucks.

[Frostdaddy]

S&M blew me away. I love watcing the DVD of it.

[temp100]

Probably Load.

I actually like Black quite a lot - but I like it as a general rock album - I don't think of it as a Metallica thrash metal album because it's not a thrash album and it's not particularly good by Metallica standards. But it's a decent album.

[tripb19]

I like S&M because I can watch Newstead's Sadowsky's and listen to the wonderful Bassoon solo on Battery.

[aronax0195]

St. Anger

The only other Metallica album I like is Kill Em All though.

[KEALYBOY]

Probably 'Regulate...The G Funk Era'

[Shorty|*|RocK89]

There is no such thing as a good alum after the Black album.

[Grunge]

Load/Reload. The Loads WERE good and interesting albums, regardless of how thrashy they were. Hell, I consider them as good as Master of Puppets.

St. Anger sucked, though.

[Kreagerwaves]

The "red album"
filled with Motorhead covers
Its a rare album recorded at wiskey a go go
at Lemmy's birthday party.
Comes in a red sleave style case and comes with a poster one cd and guitar pick.

[shdwpuppet]

Reload ftw.

[temp100]

The "red album"
filled with Motorhead covers
Its a rare album recorded at wiskey a go go
at Lemmy's birthday party.
Comes in a red sleave style case and comes with a poster one cd and guitar pick.
Wow, I can't say I've ever heard of that album. Do you have it?

[Kreagerwaves]

Wow, I can't say I've ever heard of that album. Do you have it?

Yes.
I got it from the big HMV on Young st in Toronto.

[strikeandburn]

St Anger probably, frantic isint a bad song, but it still sucks.

[METALGOD42088]

im gonna say garage inc

[BaxterII]

...And Justice For All or Ride The Lightning

[MiKe]

...And Justice For All or Ride The Lightning

He said AFTER the black album.
For me.......probably Live Shit: Binge & Purge.

[BaxterII]

He said AFTER the black album.
For me.......probably Live Shit.
Oops, didn't read that part.

S&M.

[MiKe]

Oops, didn't read that part.

S&M.

LMAO, he also said S&M doesn't count.

[Lounge Fly]

the alternative 90's killed metallica