Best CURRENT all around QB?

[jmbarlow2001]

i think im gonna go with donnovan mcnabb

[napolandynamite]

I'd say Daunte Culpepper. He can do it all. In the next few years I think David Carr will be one of the best.

[piggyman18]

You are both wrong. It is Bradlee Van Pelt.

[Devastation]

Tim Couch.


10 Characters.

[Spike Lee]

All around obviously Payton Manning. Leadership, and talent.

[jmbarlow2001]

All around obviously Payton Manning. Leadership, and talent.

i would agree with you if you were to say the best QB period... but i am asking about the best all around QB.... leadership, mobility, passing, awareness, toughness... all that good stuff

[PotIsYourFriend]

David Carr











Wait, this is the thread for best hair for a QB?

[Spike Lee]

i would agree with you if you were to say the best QB period... but i am asking about the best all around QB.... leadership, mobility, passing, awareness, toughness... all that good stuff
Best all around and best qb? What is the diffrence.
leadership,: Tom Brady,
mobility, : Vick
passing, : Payton Manning
awareness, :Favre
toughness: Favre? Manning?
Big Ben Maybe.

[NYG 5]

manning has better awareness cuz he reads coverages better. favre has the toughness cuz hes favre

[Dual]

D-Nabb.

He's Vick + Culpepper + more shit.

[PhyuckYu]

Shane Falco.

[jmbarlow2001]

ya im still going with mcnabb.... hes got the whole package

[TheDawgPound72]

Just because Manning doesn't run means that he's not the best overall QB. What seperates him from the rest is his reads. Basically every play, he audibles before the snap, and I'm not gonna go against someone who threw for 49 TDs.

[eldawg]

IMHO, Payton Manning.

[Obeseanorexic23]

Best all around: Would be Manning...Culpepper right behind
best clutch QB when it counts; Tom Brady
Toughness: Farve and Brady
Awareness: definitely Brady he is always calm no matter if they are blitzing or not
Mobility:Vick or Culpepper
Leadership: Brady, Farve, and Manning

[ColdShock]

I would have to say Peyton Manning is the best all around QB. He is the best student of the game. Nobody learns more about the other teams then him. He reads over their formations while the defense is on the field. Leadership i would have to go with brady as much as i hate him. Toughness in my mind is no question steve mcnair. he has played through more injuries then any other wb in the league. When you look at how many times he has been questionable for the game and played its amazing.

[Gordon Bombay]

andre ware




with a close second going to daunte culpepper

[Obeseanorexic23]

Thats a good point McNair has always pushed through with his injuries he is definitely up their for toughness

[wsuwarrior]

um.....how about brett favre for toughness. Ya know, considering he has played over 200 consecutive games....how many qbs can play a full season after breaking a thumb?

But yea steve mcnair is tougher :rolleyes:

[PotIsYourFriend]

um.....how about brett favre for toughness. Ya know, considering he has played over 200 consecutive games....how many qbs can play a full season after breaking a thumb?

But yea steve mcnair is tougher :rolleyes:




I'm so sick of this guy.. Every announcer kisses this guys ass.. I bet Brett never has to whip his own ass.......

[ColdShock]

I'm so sick of this guy.. Every announcer kisses this guys ass.. I bet Brett never has to whip his own ass.......


Sure he is a little overhyped but you cannot argue the guy is a great qb. Hes gonna throw for his 50,000th yard this year. He will also reach 400 td's this year and will have a 60-65 % completion percentage this for his career. Those are extremely tough to come by in a Qb.


And you can tell he's pretty good considering this is coming from a Vikings Fan.

[BucsMagicUK]

Brian "MVP" Griese.

End of debate. :cool:

[Nerdcraft]

Best all around and best qb? What is the diffrence.
leadership,: Tom Brady,
mobility, : Vick
passing, : Payton Manning
awareness, :Favre
toughness: Favre? Manning?
Big Ben Maybe.
You're...You're kidding right? Manning for toughness? Good god....Culpepper is the best all around QB. He has the best arm in the game and he is more athletic than Manning.

[JMac453]

Peyton Manning is the best current all-around QB. QB's weren't meant to run around and do all this shit that Vick and McNabb do. If you go by what the definition of a quarterback is, and how they were originally supposed to play, it's bar-none Peyton Manning. Actually...scratch all that crap I just said.

Here's all you need to know about Peyton Manning: He WILL be the greatest QB of all time (at least statistically...I don't know if he'll be able to get that ring).

[IsItLiquidOrICE]

Tom Brady > Peyton Manning and every other QB

[STiSchucky]

Daunte Culpepper


Daunte Culpepper

Daunte C....


why is Mcnabb even on the list, any qb who consistently over throws/throws at the shoe laces shouldnt be there.

[Nick is cool]

best ever - joe montana (dont say marino just cause he has best records)

best now not under pressure- dante culpepper

best under pressure- tom brady

[1iNcHWoNDeR]

Dan Marino was the best. Now it has to be....well I just don't know. I would have to say Donovan.

600 post! Whoo Hoo!

[wsuwarrior]

You're...You're kidding right? Manning for toughness? Good god....Culpepper is the best all around QB. He has the best arm in the game and he is more athletic than Manning.


manning is second to favre for most consecutive games started (by an active quarterback anyway)

Didnt he break his jaw in a game and kept playing?

[Jk1725]

yaafm if you say mcnabb
1.Manning
2.Cullpepper
3.favre
4.brady
5.green
6.McNabb

[NYG 5]

Best all around: Would be Manning...Culpepper right behind
best clutch QB when it counts; Tom Brady
Toughness: Farve and Brady
Awareness: definitely Brady he is always calm no matter if they are blitzing or not
Mobility:Vick or Culpepper
Leadership: Brady, Farve, and Manning
how does brady get ranked with favre in toughness, nobody else comes close except maybe mcnair, and warner back in the day

[Kommercial]

I'd say Daunte Culpepper. He can do it all. In the next few years I think David Carr will be one of the best.

That's my exact thought.

Peyton Manning beat him out last year because they're cheap. They would get the running back to fun down the field, then get Peyton to throw a 3-yard touchdown pass. :insane:

[Nick is cool]

yaafm if you say mcnabb
1.Manning
2.Cullpepper
3.favre
4.brady
5.green
6.McNabb


wow.. farve definatley isnt 3rd anymore, hes not as good as he was when he was young, back then he took chances and always came out with a completed pass, now he still takes chances but he doesnt succeed as much

[wils0646]

wow.. farve definatley isnt 3rd anymore, hes not as good as he was when he was young, back then he took chances and always came out with a completed pass, now he still takes chances but he doesnt succeed as much

Yea, I agree. He's still top 5 though. Here are my rankings:

1. Manning
2. Culpepper
3. McNabb
4. Brady
5. Favre

[Jk1725]

Peyton Manning beat him out last year because they're cheap. They would get the running back to fun down the field, then get Peyton to throw a 3-yard touchdown pass.
That explains why peyton had something like 4557 yards throwing and culpepper had maybe a 100 more
btw Edge shouldn't get that big contract if he is "funning" down the field




p.s favre isn't supposed to be third in my thing idk why i put him there

[cr0p]

Can I ask u Guys what are the best QB' ever?

like Montana etc.?

[Wu-tang]

i would agree with you if you were to say the best QB period... but i am asking about the best all around QB

What the fuck?



I'd pick Manning.

[k_tull88]

Brett Favre
Tom Brady
Donovan McNabb
Peyton Manning

[ryankj]

Toughness in my mind is no question steve mcnair. he has played through more injuries then any other wb in the league. When you look at how many times he has been questionable for the game and played its amazing.

Did Mcnair ever recieve a concussion, then go back on the field and throw for a touchdown?

Didn't think so.

http://www.favremadness.com/injury.html

and

http://sportsillustrated.cnn.com/football/nfl/players/1025/injuries.html

[jmbarlow2001]

Can I ask u Guys what are the best QB' ever?

like Montana etc.?

in my opinion... best ever

joe montana
dan marino
troy aikman
steve young
john elway

[Spike Lee]

troy should be there. And Im a boy's fan.

[Obeseanorexic23]

Marino nobody can even match his numbers...not even Farve can.....too bad Marino never won a super bowl though that was his only downfall...if he would have won a couple he would be elevated too super elite of QB's....He is still considered by many to be the best or Montana but Montana also won super Bowls...ahhh welll

[MegaSuperdude]

Daunte Culpepper for sho! He has an arm like a tank, can run better than some RB... and he's still a good leader.

[Nick is cool]

Can I ask u Guys what are the best QB' ever?

like Montana etc.?


1: montana
2: john elway
3:steve young
4:roger stoughbaugh

[ChrisKatz001]

Brady? :)

[HydeBlitz]

Statistically (Regular Season) Peyton
Statistically (Post Season) Tom Brady
Statistically (playoffs excludign superbowls) tie Brady and McNabb
Raw talent Mike Vick
overall (Run and Gun) Daunte Culpepper

for current qb's

[Rylinkus]

People really need to get off the Brett Favre bandwagon. He's a cool guy and all and you know he's tough and loves playing the game.... But he throws SOO many damn interceptions. Mannings first few years the biggest criticisms you could make of him were his td/int numbers. Well look at Favres. He's only has a few seasons where he didn't throw more interceptions then average.

[beardo]

im saying culpepper, great numbers, good speed, hard to take down because he is pretty big (says dwight freeny) and a good leader...i liek daunte...but i love my browns....yea i know they suck

[Nick is cool]

People really need to get off the Brett Favre bandwagon. He's a cool guy and all and you know he's tough and loves playing the game.... But he throws SOO many damn interceptions. Mannings first few years the biggest criticisms you could make of him were his td/int numbers. Well look at Favres. He's only has a few seasons where he didn't throw more interceptions then average.


Completely right about farve. It pisses me off when the announcers praise him the whole game, and they find away to make it non negative when he throws a pic.

[Spike Lee]

I dont like either when they parise Favre. They always ay Favre is still one of the best. Come on. He throws interceptions. Not on top. Not to sure if he is one of the best qb's in the league. I also meant to say troy probobly shouldnt be that high on the list, but I aint one to comment on that.

[wils0646]

I dont like either when they parise Favre. They always ay Favre is still one of the best. Come on. He throws interceptions. Not on top. Not to sure if he is one of the best qb's in the league. I also meant to say troy probobly shouldnt be that high on the list, but I aint one to comment on that.

He's still a top 5 QB in this league. Don't kid yourself. He may be losing a step from his past years, but he's still damn good.

[Nick is cool]

He's good when hes not throwing pics, hes almost as good as a peyton manning type quarterback when hes not throwing pics, but he throws so many, and we all remember the game last season where he went to throw it and it went 20 yards behind him, lol.